Wine Games for Father’s Day: Can Dad Guess These Bottle Prices?

Tired of the same old Father’s Day routine? This year, swap out the usual gifts and plan something interactive. A wine tasting game is a fun, relaxed way to celebrate, especially when Dad’s the one doing the guessing. Whether you're hosting on a Manhattan rooftop, in your apartment, or out on the patio, this is one of those simple ideas that makes the day feel special.

How to Host a Wine Tasting Party for Father’s Day

Here’s how it works: pour a few mystery wines without showing the labels, and let Dad guess which bottles are budget-friendly and which ones break the bank. You’ll be surprised how often the underdog steals the show.

You don’t need to be a sommelier to pull this off. Just grab three to five wines across different price points (we’ve got recommendations below), set out some tasting glasses, and prep a few easy snacks, think cheeses, olives, and crackers. Keep it casual but intentional. Make sure your lineup includes a mix of styles: maybe a bold red, a crisp white, and something unexpected like a chilled rosé or mineral-driven French white. Give each wine a number, let everyone jot down their price guesses, and save the big reveal for the end.

This isn't about who knows the most about wine. It’s about connection, conversation, and a few lighthearted surprises. Let Dad take the lead and have fun describing each wine, even if all he says is “tastes like wine.” Add some background music, dim the lights, and enjoy a laid-back tasting with a Manhattan vibe.

Our Top Picks for Father’s Day Wines

At Vino Fine Wines & Spirits we’ve curated a selection of bottles perfect for Father’s Day wine games. Here are a few ideas to get you started:

Value Pick: Bold Reds Under $15 That Punch Above Their Weight

These wines may be easy on the wallet, but they’re not holding back on flavor. Each bottle brings a bold, approachable character to the table. It is perfect for stumping Dad during the big reveal.

Gravelly Ford Cabernet Sauvignon

This smooth-sipping red leans into juicy plum and black cherry flavors with a soft, mellow finish. It's a great intro for anyone easing into Cabernet, and it’ll easily pass for something more premium in a blind tasting.

Capogiro Montepulciano d'Abruzzo

Round, plush, and just the right touch of spice, this Montepulciano keeps things rich without being heavy. It’s the kind of red you pour once and hear, “Wait… how much was this?”

Terra Vega Cabernet Sauvignon (Kosher)

This bottle blends ripe fruit and subtle spice in a smooth, easy-drinking style. The kosher label is a bonus, but even beyond that, it’s a solid crowd-pleaser that won’t raise any budget red flags.

Protocolo Tempranillo Tinto

Dark berries and soft tannins give this red a plush, velvety feel. Protocolo has just enough structure to feel “serious,” but it’s still playful enough for any casual wine game.

Tinedo Tempranillo Ja!

Light, fresh, and a little fruity, this young Tempranillo brings just the right amount of spice to keep things interesting. It's a fun bottle that can easily trip up even the self-proclaimed wine experts in the room.

Mid-Range Favorite: Smooth Pinots and Crisp Sauvignon Blancs in the $20–30 Range

This tier is where things get interesting. These bottles bring polish, personality, and enough complexity to throw Dad off his game. Whether he leans red or white, this lineup is built to impress without going overboard.

Comtesse Marion Pinot Noir

Light and refined, this Pinot Noir offers gentle red berry notes layered with a whisper of earth. It’s a smooth operator, perfect for anyone who likes their reds delicate but not dull.

Folly of the Beast Pinot Noir

Fruit-forward with a plush, silky feel, this one brings cherry and warm spice to the glass. Folly of the Beast is the kind of Pinot that makes you pause mid-sip and say, “Okay, this one’s gotta be expensive.”

Carneros Ranch Pinot Noir

This bottle strikes a great balance, vibrant red fruit meets a grounded, earthy backbone. The smooth tannins and silky texture make Carneros Ranch Pinot Noir a standout for a seated tasting or casual sip.

Huia Sauvignon Blanc

Bright, zesty, and full of tropical flair, this New Zealand white comes alive with citrus and juicy passionfruit. The crisp finish keeps Huia Sauvignon Blanc fresh and mouthwatering.

Bloodroot Sauvignon Blanc

With its burst of citrus and fragrant nose, this wine brings both energy and elegance to the table. Bloodroot Sauvignon Blanc is refreshing and bold, with a finish that keeps you coming back for another taste.

Macari Sauvignon Blanc

From the North Fork of Long Island, this bottle keeps things local and lively. Expect a clean, citrusy profile with hints of tropical fruit and just the right snap of acidity. Macari Sauvignon Blanc is a great pick for summer sipping and price-guessing alike.

Premium Choice: Napa Cabernets and Refined French Wines That’ll Keep Everyone Guessing

For the final round of your Father’s Day wine game, bring out the heavy hitters. These wines are polished, complex, and full of character, the kind of bottles that make everyone pause before writing down their guesses. Whether you go bold with a Napa Cab or refined with a French classic, this lineup keeps things interesting to the very last glass.

Scholar & Mason Cabernet Sauvignon

Bold and structured, this Napa pick brings dark fruit and a touch of oak spice. This Cabernet Sauvignon has the kind of depth that feels expensive and drinks that way, too.

Hardin Cabernet Sauvignon

Smooth and powerful, this bottle layers blackberry and mocha with silky tannins. Hardin Cabernet Sauvignon is rich without being overwhelming, ideal for a final round of guesswork.

Meadowcroft Cabernet Sauvignon

Think bold black fruit, a little dark chocolate, and a whisper of toast. This Napa Cab is a classic crowd-pleaser with just enough edge to keep people guessing.

Domaine Begue-Mathiot Chablis

Bright and mineral-driven, this French white opens with crisp green apple, citrus, and a clean, stony finish. Its elegance makes it a perfect curveball for the tasting game.

Domaine Anita Chenas Cuvee P’tit Co

Silky and expressive, this Chénas offers layers of red berry and floral notes with a smooth finish. It’s light on its feet but full of personality, great for Pinot lovers looking for something different.

Raphaelle Guyot Aligote

Fresh, crisp, and slightly citrusy, this Aligoté has a lean, mineral character that keeps things sharp. It’s a refined alternative to Chardonnay and a fun wildcard to toss into the mix.

All bottles are available in-store or online, right here in Manhattan. Whether you're a wine newbie or a seasoned sipper, we’ll help you find the right mix for your tasting lineup.

Level Up Your Father’s Day Wine Games

Whether you're planning a low-key afternoon or a full-blown tasting party, Father’s Day wines should feel just as thoughtful as the rest of the day. It’s not about spending big, it’s about sharing something memorable. Wine games bring everyone to the table, glass in hand, with something to talk about.

Think you can outsmart Dad? Grab your bottles, set the stage, and let the guessing begin. Stop by Vino Fine Wines & Spirits in Manhattan to stock up for your Father’s Day tasting party. We’ll help you find the right mix to keep Dad smiling, and maybe even second-guessing his wine instincts.